Are You My First? S1:E4

The First Time

Colton Underwood and Kaitlyn Bristowe host the virgins in paradise and kick off their first challenge. Crushes and love triangles quickly form, and when a sexy new arrival shows up, some connections may come to a crashing halt before they even begin.

Let's Talk About Sex

Women swoon over the new arrival, threatening current connections. One virgin questions her crush after learning he's been smooth-talking other girls. A spicy challenge tests their sexual knowledge, and one couple shares the first kiss of the season!

The Virgin Sacrifice

A broken promise leads one woman to explore a previous relationship, meanwhile one guy is blindsided when a connection reveals feelings for someone else. The first Virgin Sacrifice rocks the villa, and an unexpected departure leaves one virgin devastated.

F-Boys for Life

A high-flying date nosedives, leaving one virgin guarded. A shocking breakup exposes the f-boys on the island. One woman second-guesses the connection she left behind, while another confronts her partner when the truth about his feelings are revealed.

Never Have I Ever

The Virgin Sacrifice explodes with surprises. Two friends create a splash as they compete for a date with the same woman. One woman experiences a few firsts on her date. Two virgins realize their love interests may be more into each other than them.

The First Love Shack

Virgins lay their hearts on the line during the Virgin Sacrifice. Three new guys spice things up on the Island. A salsa class heats up with a steamy kiss while one couple bonds in the Love Shack.

A Tight Spot

Laughter quickly turns to tears when two couples have their relationships roasted in front of the group. One virgin fears her intimacy struggles could jeopardize her promising connection, while another is determined to find romance before time runs out.

The Virgin Betrayal

One virgin is furious when her crush is taken on a date by another girl, fueling conflict. A sexy paint session pushes one couple out of their comfort zone. The final Virgin Sacrifice delivers shocking choices and emotional goodbyes that shake the villa.

The Big Finish

In the season finale, one woman ends her love triangle. The final couples shack up and out of their comfort zones. Finally, the virgins decide if they will take their relationship off the island.