Sentimental Value

FULL SPOILER-FREE REVIEW @ https://talkingfilms.net/sentimental-value-review-joachim-triers-profound-meditation-on-art-grief-and-forgiveness/

"Sentimental Value is, ultimately, a mature and profoundly moving movie that resonates with the authorial mark of Joachim Trier.

The film triumphs thanks to the strength of its narrative and the excellence of the four central performances. It's a meditation on inherited pain, the intricate cost of artistic creation, and the difficult, yet essential, path to forgiveness and reconciliation. The assured direction and the melancholic atmosphere consolidate Trier's position as one of the most skillful chroniclers of human fragility.

It's a story that feels familiar, intimate, and, above all, reminds us that true sentimental value lies in the irreducible and, at times, painful bonds that define us."

Rating: B+

When a film has the capacity to provide a template for overcoming domestic discord, promoting forgiveness and helping to heal one’s past, it’s to be truly commended for going beyond being mere entertainment or even an admired artform. It aspires to become a noble, laudable cinematic godsend, one verging on providing a valuable service to those requiring much-needed guidance and direction in their lives. At the risk of exaggeration, such is the case with the latest offering from writer-director Joachim Trier, arguably the best work of his storied career. When aging, esteemed Scandinavian filmmaker Gustav Borg (Stellan Skarsgård) unexpectedly reconnects with the family from which he has long been estranged, his two adult daughters, Nora (Renate Reinsve) and Agnes (Inga Ibsdotter Lilleaas), are baffled by his sudden reentry into their lives. After years of conflict and incessant arguing with his wife, Gustav departed without warning, leaving his now-recently deceased spouse to raise their two daughters on her own. Despite the challenges associated with such circumstances, Nora would go on to become a successful, if troubled and lonely, stage actress, while Agnes went on to live a comparatively stable life as a wife and mother. Gustav, meanwhile, launched into a noteworthy filmmaking career, though, due to the onset of failing health and problem drinking, he hasn’t worked on a new project for some time. However, with his re-emergence into his daughters’ lives, he now hopes to change that – by making a movie that he views as a legacy production, a less-than-veiled autobiographical piece that he claims to have written for Nora and for which he would like her to play the lead. But, given the longstanding bitterness between Nora and her father, she turns him down, a major setback for his plans to proceed – that is, until Gustav meets a young American rising star, Rachel Kemp (Elle Fanning), to whom he offers the part. The director’s casting choice, in turn, unleashes a barr...

Sisters “Nora” (Renate Reinsve) and “Agnes” (Inga Ibsdotter Lilleaas) are the daughters of acclaimed film director “Gustav” (Stellan Skarsgård). The former, a theatrical actor, is a bit of a loner. The latter is a little more balanced, married to “Even” (Andreas Stoltenberg Granerud) and has a son “Erik” (Øyvind Hesjedal Loven). Both have a strained relationship with their father. His past successes suggests that he was rarely there, in any qualitative sense, when they were growing up nor when tragedy impacted on the family in later years. He is currently benefitting from a bit of a revival of interest in one of his early works - a film that featured “Agnes” and he has attracted the attentions of global superstar “Rachel” (Elle Fanning). Now feeling a little revitalised, he presents a script to “Nora” that he hopes she will agree to do. She is polite but clearly wants as little to do with him as she can get away with, and so when she declines he offers it to the enthusiastic “Rachel”. Fanning serves quite well for much of the rest of the film as a conduit for exposing not just the content of a script that sails close to home, but that also addresses head-on some of the issues that the siblings have with their dad and that he understands - albeit, perhaps, belatedly. Things come to more of an head with “Agnes” when he decides that the affable young “Erik” could have a role in the film too, and now a more complete family perspective begins to emerge. I wasn’t bowled over by the story, to be honest. I’ve seen plenty of films that depict dysfunctional family’s where the kids resent their successful if often absent parents. This, though, is a much more solid and characterful study that introduces elements of joy, sadness, bitterness and potential reconciliation to a story that develops gradually for a couple of hours of intimately photographed and scripted cinema. It’s asks many a recognisable question about the aspirations of parents for children, jealousies and ambitio...